Q:  What did the stamp say to the envelope on Valentines Day?

A: I'm stuck on you!!

Q: What is a vampire's sweetheart called?

A: His ghoul-friend.

Q: What kind of flowers do you never give on Valentine's Day?

    A: Cauliflowers!

We have all the best materials for homemade Valentines, Valentine gift bags, or fun premade Valentines for the whole class!


The store is experiencing telephone difficulties.  Our main line is not working.  Please call 212 396-4908 or  email questions and orders to This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it .  We apologize for any inconvenience. 



Check out our upcoming events!

Call 212 744 8510 for suggestions!

toys-baby.jpg toys-toddler.jpg toys-pre-k.jpg toys-bigkids.jpg toys-tweens.jpg


Questions? Call (212) 744-8510

Contact us:

P: 212 744-8510 



Store Hours:

M-F: 9-6

Sat: 10-5:30

Sun: 10-5

1010 Lexington Ave.
(btwn 72nd and 73rd)

New York, NY 10021 



Our customers are amazing and deserve the very best!

Toy Wish List
Party Favors
Free Delivery Zone
Same Day Delivery

Mary Arnold Toys Newsletter Sign-Up